球員真正浪費的是什麼?不是汗水


🇨🇳🇬🇧 This is a bilingual weekly newsletter.

👇 Scroll to bottom for ENGLISH VERSION

點擊閱讀網頁版(閱讀體驗更好)

Read Web Version Here


「只要持續努力就會達到目標」是錯的。唯有在正確的方法上投注足夠的時間,才能真正進步。別無他法。

最近重讀 刻意練習 (Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise),書中前言的這句話引起我很大的共鳴,我還特地分享到 Facebook。

朋友莊樹聰教練隨後轉發,並結合他在之前去希臘參加歐洲聯賽主教練委員會教練峰會(EHCB Coaches Congress)的心得,提出了新的觀點,成為本週這篇文章的靈感來源:既然在最高層級時間是如此稀缺,教練該如何讓每一分鐘都發揮最大意義?

沒有多餘的時間浪費

EuroLeague 那些頂尖職業隊,並沒有無止境的訓練時數。舟車勞頓、恢復時間、緊湊的賽程,讓實際訓練時間極度有限。每一分鐘一旦被浪費,就永遠回不來。

對球員而言,訓練必須短、專注、貼近比賽。每一個訓練環節都要和實戰相連,每一次暫停都必須有明確的教學。對教練而言,負擔反而更大:更多影片要剪輯、更多戰術要準備、更多細節要設計,確保每一分鐘都能帶來學習。往往在場上看不到的準備時間,是場上實際訓練的兩倍甚至三倍。

責任的重心改變了。進步不只是球員「更努力」,而是教練「更聰明」地準備。而在現代籃球裡,最聰明的訓練,往往比最長的訓練更有價值。

為什麼基層發展更關鍵

既然職業球隊無法回頭補課,那麼基礎應該在哪裡建立?答案很明顯:基層。

樹聰教練的提醒很直接:等到球員站上最高層級時,要再修正決策、空間感或比賽閱讀能力,已經太難。職業環境只能往前走,幾乎沒有時間回頭。

這正是 刻意練習 所強調的:有效練習不是盲目堆疊時數,而是針對弱點,透過反覆回饋去修正。

如果年輕球員在成長過程中只是「努力苦練」,沒有設計和反思,他們終將撞上瓶頸,因為精英層級根本沒有時間替他們重建基礎。就像摩天大樓蓋好後才要補地基,代價將極其龐大且痛苦。

「以後再學」的危險信念

我們常常還是用時數來衡量投入。球員加練幾個小時,家長把辛苦等同於成長,教練拉長練習,以為時間越長進步越快。這幾乎是文化的反射動作:越辛苦就代表越認真。但認真不代表結果。

現實更殘酷:錯誤的努力,其實是浪費機會。當我們延後正確的教學,其實是在拿「時間」這個唯一不可逆的資源來賭。等到球員進入大學或半職業層級,想要補課就會困難重重。當然,依舊有可能透過反覆糾正去重學,但過程艱辛,成本極高,甚至伴隨挫折。原本應該自然養成的習慣,變成要硬生生重新雕塑。

「以後」幾乎總是等於「更困難的以後」。如果放太久,最後就會演變成「永遠不會」。

從努力到設計、效率與時間

回顧之前寫過領航猿主帥卡總的《練得多,不如練得對》,以及領航猿助教唐偉傑(AJ)的《為什麼單靠努力不足以讓球員進步》,加上這次樹聰教練的反思,這三位教練的提醒,勾勒出清晰的方向:

  • 設計(AJ 教練):進步必須被規劃,而不是碰運氣。
  • 效率(卡總):短而專注的訓練,勝過冗長卻空洞的時數。
  • 時間(樹聰教練):錯過基層的黃金期,再來補救代價極大。

樹聰教練的觀察,和 AJ 以及卡總的理念一脈相承:努力本身永遠不夠。真正的進步需要設計、效率與時間三者的平衡。

他們來自不同的背景,台灣、西班牙、馬來西亞,卻說著同樣的語言。當來自不同脈絡的經驗彼此呼應,這就不只是地方問題,而是一個籃球文化的普遍真理。

最後的思考

樹聰教練在他的貼文留下一道問題:這些觀點對我們有什麼啟發?

我想,答案應該是:從還擁有時間的基層開始。越早尊重時間,後續的潛力就越能被釋放。越早重視質量而非數量,球員在關鍵時刻才更有可能挺身而出。

每一分鐘都很重要。浪費了,就永遠追不回來。

感謝你抽空閱讀。我們下週再見!

Jordan

如果這篇文章讓你有所共鳴,歡迎訂閱我的 newsletter,或到 Buy Me A Coffee 支持我的創作。你的支持,能幫助我持續分享更多關於籃球、文化與成長的故事。


Why Every Minute Counts in Basketball Player Development

“Persistent effort will get you to your goal” is WRONG. Only by investing enough time with the right method can you truly improve. There's no other way.

Rereading Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise (刻意練習) reminded me of that. A line from the preface hit hard, so I shared it on Facebook.

Coach Su Chung then shared it and added reflections from the EHCB Coaches Congress in Greece he attended recently. His perspective sparked this week’s newsletter: if time is scarce at the top, how do we make every minute meaningful?

Elite Teams Have No Time to Waste

Elite clubs in the EuroLeague don’t enjoy endless practice hours. Travel, recovery, and packed schedules squeeze contact time. Every wasted minute is gone for good.

For players, practices are short, sharp, and game-linked. For coaches, the burden grows: more film to cut, more plans to refine, more drills to design, so every session teaches something that shows up on the floor.

In modern basketball, the smartest practice is worth more than the longest one.

Why Grassroots Becomes Critical

If pros can’t rewind to fix basics, where should they be learned? At the grassroots, where space, patience, and repetition still exist.

Su Chung’s point is simple: by the time athletes reach the top, it’s far harder to repair foundational gaps in decision-making, spacing, or reading the game. Professional environments move forward; they rarely have time to go back.

This is Peak in action. Deliberate practice targets weaknesses with feedback; it doesn’t pile on empty hours.

If youth players spend formative years only “working hard,” they’ll hit a wall later because elite teams don’t have minutes to reteach fundamentals. Trying to fix a foundation after the skyscraper is up is costly and painful.

The Dangerous Belief in “Later”

Too often we still measure dedication by hours. Players boast about extra sessions. Parents equate sacrifice with progress. Coaches extend practices, thinking more time equals more growth.

Reality is harsher: misapplied effort is opportunity lost. Delay proper teaching and you gamble with the one resource you can’t replenish—time. By university or semi-pro level, learning the fundamentals becomes far more difficult. You can unlearn bad habits and rebuild skills, but it takes much more effort and often comes with setbacks. What could have been natural becomes an uphill climb.

“Later” almost always turns into “much harder later.” Leave it long enough, and it slips into “never.”

From Effort to Design, Efficiency, and Time

Looking back at the past newsletters—Coach Iurgi Caminos on “It’s not how much you practice, it’s how well you practice,”, Coach Tang Weijie (AJ) on “Why Hard Work Alone Won’t Make a Player Better,” and now Coach Shu Cong's reflection , we see a trilogy that points to one clear path forward.

  • Design (Coach AJ): Progress must be planned, not left to chance.
  • Efficiency (Coach Caminos): Short, focused sessions beat long, empty hours.
  • Time (Coach Su Chung): What isn’t taught early is expensive to recover later.

What Coach Su Chung observed aligns with Coach AJ and Coach Caminos: effort alone isn’t enough. Development anywhere in the world must value design, efficiency, and time over sheer hours.

Three coaches from different backgrounds—Taiwan, Spain, and Malaysia—converge on the same truth. When lessons rhyme across contexts, the issue isn’t local; it’s cultural.

Final Reflection

Coach Su Chung asked in his post: How do these lessons apply to us here?

I think the answer would be: start where time still exists—at the grassroots. Respect minutes early to unlock potential later. Prioritize quality over quantity so players can stand tall when the game is on the line.

Every minute counts. Waste it early, and you’ll pay for it forever.

Thanks for reading. See you again next week.

— Jordan

If this reflection resonates, you can subscribe to the newsletter for more stories like this—or support the work on Buy Me A Coffee. Your support helps me keep sharing insights that connect basketball, culture, and growth.

The Jordan Letters

Reveal the hidden layers of basketball through exclusive insights and stories (Without the clutter of generic news). Join 1000+ of readers and get the latest issue sent straight to your inbox.

Read more from The Jordan Letters

🇨🇳🇬🇧 This is a bilingual weekly newsletter. 👇 Scroll to bottom for ENGLISH VERSION 點擊閱讀網頁版Read web version here 我們都看過這樣的場景:球隊不斷傳導,球在外圍流動,五次、六次、七次傳球。看起來節奏流暢、配合漂亮,但最終卻往往以一個倉促、受干擾的出手結束。 球是有在動,可防守卻始終沒被真正打開。那一回合看似團隊合作,實際上只是「動作多於意圖」的空轉。 許多教練在教進攻時,就像在跑一份清單:跑戰術、站好位置、等好機會。但他們常常忽略了現代籃球最關鍵的一個核心概念。 正如克利夫蘭騎士隊助理教練 Alex Sarama 所說,這個被忽略的概念,其實才是一切的關鍵:「大多數教練教進攻時,都像在跑清單:跑戰術、站定位、等好球出現。但他們錯過了一個重點,那不是一套戰術,也不是一個陣型,而是一個『優勢』。」 Sarama 所提出的「多米諾哲學」(Dominoes Philosophy)提供了一種全新的思維方式。重點不再是執行戰術模式,而是創造、辨識、並轉化「優勢」。...

🇨🇳🇬🇧 This is a bilingual weekly newsletter. 👇 Scroll to bottom for ENGLISH VERSION 點擊閱讀網頁版Read web version here 「這裡沒人把你當一回事。」 挑戰傳統,往往比提出新方法更難。 最近有位朋友向我推薦了一本書:Alex Sarama 所著的《Transforming Basketball: Changing How We Think About Basketball Performance》。去年7月,他受聘為 NBA 克利夫蘭騎士隊的球員發展總監,今年夏天正式升為球隊的助理教練。 我隨手翻開幾頁便被吸引住了。書中許多概念完全顛覆了我們長期以來在亞洲球館裡反覆操作的訓練方式。讀得越多,我就越覺得必須把這些想法分享給大家。 一個挑戰傳統的框架 Sarama 並不是全盤否定傳統。他承認老派教練與舊的方法在他們的那個年代具有劃時代的價值。但他同時也提出一個發人深省的觀點:在今日這個研究與方法論都在不斷精進的時代,墨守成規,本身就是一種風險。 這讓我想起林書豪的訓練師 Josh...

🇨🇳🇬🇧 This is a bilingual weekly newsletter. 👇 Scroll to bottom for ENGLISH VERSION 點擊閱讀網頁版Read web version here 為期兩天的 Bang Lee Skill Lab 精英籃球訓練營在上周末圓滿結束,在 Bang Lee 教練回國前,我和他做了一次簡單的訪問。他沒有再談技術細節或場上的高光時刻,而是留下了三個關鍵詞: 自信 聆聽 強度 他說,這是大馬年輕球員未來成長最需要補上的部分。天賦不是問題,「原材料」我們都有,而如何把潛力轉化為實力,正是我們面前最值得期待的方向。 除了 Bang Lee 的觀察,我自己也注意到另一個提升空間:核心力量、平衡與協調能力。這些基礎條件不像灌籃或快攻那樣直觀,但如果能補強它們,其他技術將更穩固。 一、自信 —— 成長的第一道門檻 Bang Lee 對我們球員的身體條件感到驚訝:身高、體格、速度,甚至可以灌籃,條件一應俱全。這代表我們已具備天賦,只差一步,就是建立真正的信念。...